Inside the Numbers: How Self-Storage Investments Build Wealth Over Time

The resilience of self-storage demand is encapsulated by the “6 Ds.” Historically, demand was tied to four primary drivers: Dislocation (moving), Divorce, Death, and Downsizing.² In the modern era, two additional factors, Distribution (use by small businesses for inventory) and Decluttering (driven by increased consumer wealth and smaller residences), have expanded the demand base.² These key life events are constant factors regardless of the immediate economic climate. When economic times are favorable, people acquire more possessions and need space; when times are difficult, they downsize residences or businesses utilize storage for temporary inventory management. This dual-purpose function ensures that self-storage facilities remain consistently in demand.

Analysis of consumer behavior confirms this sustained need. Search interest in self-storage surged 88% since 2020, reaching a record 25 million annual searches in 2024.² Furthermore, a significant portion of the population relies heavily on storage solutions, with one in five Americans dedicating 500 square feet or more of their homes strictly to storage, and 39% reporting they have converted a guest bedroom into a storage room in the past year.⁴ This points to a deep, underlying societal need for external space that transcends short-term market fluctuations.

---

Why Self-Storage Excels as a Long-Term Investment

The market performance of self-storage illustrates its defensive qualities. While its demand is often considered counter-cyclical, the data shows that its stability translates into a comparatively low correlation with other asset classes, such as traditional residential or office properties.⁵ This means that when other CRE sectors face severe financial strain during economic downturns, self-storage often maintains steady rental rates and high occupancy levels, providing stability and reducing overall portfolio risk.³

A key driver of appreciation in this sector relates to the housing market. Although temporary softening in storage demand can occur when high home prices delay moving activity, the long-term effect of high housing costs is often increased demand for storage.⁶ As individuals rent or purchase smaller homes to cope with rising prices, the limited space within these smaller residences necessitates external storage solutions.⁶

Structural Stability and Portfolio Defense

Despite the delivery of approximately 58.5 million square feet of rentable space in 2024, the national self-storage inventory now exceeds 2 billion square feet.² The immense scale of the existing footprint suggests that new supply only marginally impacts the overall market in the long term, especially given projections for construction slowdowns.⁷ This market depth supports the thesis that established, well-located assets are positioned to maintain sustained pricing power over a long-term hold period.

---

Quantifying Self-Storage ROI: Historical Performance Metrics

Disciplined investors prioritize quantifiable historical returns and credible benchmarks. Self-storage has proven itself as more than just an alternative investment, and into a recognized institutional asset class, providing transparent performance data through indices maintained by organizations such as Nareit and the National Council of Real Estate Investment Fiduciaries (NCREIF).⁹

Benchmarking Historical Returns (CAGR)

Self-storage returns, tracked by the FTSE NAREIT Equity Self-Storage index (comprising four constituents), demonstrate competitive total returns when compared against traditional asset classes.¹¹

Performance metrics for this index show significant strength over various periods:

• 5-Year Total Return (Approx. 2019–2024): 11.60%.¹¹
• 3-Year Total Return (Approx. 2021–2024): 5.51%.¹¹
• 1-Year Total Return (Recent): 34.72%.¹¹

The disparity between the robust 5-year Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 11.60% and the more constrained 3-year return (5.51%) highlights the recent volatility induced by macroeconomic factors, specifically rising interest rates and inflation.⁸ 

However, the resilient long-term CAGR indicates that the asset class effectively absorbs and eventually overcomes short-term economic shocks. Furthermore, the 3.64% Dividend Yield reported for self-storage REITs in Q2 2024 reinforces the sector’s reliability in generating consistent, high-quality income.¹¹

---

Cash Flow Fundamentals: The Engine of Self-Storage Wealth

The self-storage asset class generates wealth primarily through a stable, predictable, and highly efficient cash flow stream. This efficiency is largely attributable to the sector’s operational structure, providing significant leverage on the expense side of the ledger.

The Operational Advantage: Low Operating Expense Ratio (OER)

The reason for this efficiency is the simplicity of management. Self-storage facilities require minimal personnel and management overhead. Unlike apartments, there is no requirement for extensive maintenance staff, complex amenity repair, or handling frequent tenant complaints about building systems.¹⁶ The capital expenditure (CapEx) list is short, primarily involving predictable items like doors and roofing. This operational simplicity reduces unexpected costs, stabilizes cash flows, and maximizes the proportion of revenue retained.¹⁶ Indeed, publicly traded storage REITs, which represent the best-in-class operational standards, report even lower OERs, ranging from 26.0% to 31.4% for the nine months ending September 30, 2024.¹⁵

The low OER provides critical operational leverage. When OER is maintained at 35%, 65 cents of every incremental dollar in gross revenue drops directly to the Net Operating Income (NOI) line.¹⁶ Because property value is calculated as a direct multiple of NOI ($Value = NOI / Cap Rate) ¹⁸, operational improvements generate an outsized increase in valuation. This leverage is the fundamental basis for rapid equity growth and the core of self-storage wealth generation.

Self-Storage Operational Benchmarks:

Metric	Industry Average (Non-REIT)	Best-in-Class (REITs)	Comparison to Multifamily (Typical)	Citation
Operating Expense Ratio (OER)	34.68% – 35%	26.0% – 31.4%	Typically 50%+	15
Stabilized Occupancy (Aug 2025)	84.69%	Higher (Low 90s)	Varies by Market	19
Average Cap Rate (Q2 2025)	5.8%	Lower (Institutional Assets)	Varies by Asset/Market	12

Occupancy Dynamics and Revenue Stability

The self-storage market saw key indicators normalize in 2023 and 2024, primarily due to deceleration in rent growth and occupancy after the post-pandemic surge.¹⁴ Despite new supply introduction and softening net demand, occupancy for stabilized facilities remained resilient, standing at 84.69% in August 2025.¹⁹ Although this represents a slight decline of 71 basis points year-over-year, it demonstrates robust underlying demand.¹⁹

While asking rents tapered in 2023 and declined by 4.5% to 5.2% year-over-year in the first quarter of 2024, facility operators have successfully maintained revenue stability through Existing Customer Rate Increases (ECRI).⁸ This ability to adjust rates for existing tenants provides a stable balance against softening asking rents for new move-ins, successfully keeping in-place rates steady or rising in several key markets.⁸ The inherent stability afforded by low operational costs provides high profit margins, enabling operators to manage these short-term revenue fluctuations effectively, thereby minimizing the impact on profitability and debt service coverage.²⁰

---

Underwriting for Long-Term Success: Structural Factors and Value-Add Strategies

Maximizing long-term returns in self-storage necessitates disciplined underwriting, strategic execution of value-add projects, and partnership with a highly competent operational sponsor. These structural factors are vital for controlling risk and accelerating appreciation.

Strategic Hold Period and Financing

Self-storage is underwritten with a multi-year horizon, typically spanning 5 to 10 years.²⁴ This duration allows for the full execution of the value-add business plan, which usually involves a period of stabilization, followed by a major financial event (refinancing or sale) to harvest the created equity.

The current capital market environment demands prudent financing. The increased cost of debt and restricted liquidity ¹⁴ create challenges, particularly for highly leveraged investors. However, this environment favors well-capitalized investors who can weather economic volatility.¹⁴ Financial projections must conservatively account for rising operating expenses (projected to increase at a rate of 3% per year in pro forma models ²⁴) and ensure adequate debt service coverage.

Value-Add Strategies to Maximize NOI

Value-add is the most reliable path to proprietary appreciation, focusing on bringing Class B/C properties up to the standards of Class A facilities.²⁹ These strategies focus on boosting revenue and efficiency:

1. Ancillary Income Generation: Aggressive management must maximize “other income,” which is assumed to rise in conjunction with rental income.²⁴ Requiring tenant insurance is a prime example of generating commission income that directly enhances NOI.¹⁸
2. Operational Modernization: Investing in modernization enhances security, reduces costs, and improves tenant experience. Simple, impactful projects include installing LED lighting, which not only ensures safety and security for after-hours access but also reduces energy consumption, leading to long-term operational savings and potential tax benefits.³⁰
3. Technological Integration: The industry is rapidly adopting advanced technology. Approximately 90% of self-storage businesses are actively utilizing Artificial Intelligence (AI) for tasks ranging from content creation to sophisticated data analytics and dynamic pricing models.³¹ Furthermore, the growth of remotely managed stores, enabled by remote management systems, improves efficiency and scalability, thereby lowering overhead and strengthening competitive positioning.¹⁷

The Essential Role of Operational Sponsorship

The selection of the operating sponsor is paramount for long-term success. The sponsor is responsible for managing and executing the complex operational and financial plan.²⁰ A highly skilled, value-add oriented sponsor can successfully transform an underperforming asset, justifying the premium paid for the facility by bringing it in line with Class A valuations.²⁹

For passive investors participating through syndication, returns are often higher than those offered by publicly traded Self-Storage REITs, provided a reputable and capable sponsor is chosen.²⁰ A sponsor’s ability to generate proprietary appreciation through improved operations, creating value irrespective of external cap rate movement, makes the investment less susceptible to macroeconomic shifts and reinforces the disciplined, long-term approach to wealth creation.²⁶

---

Portfolio Dimensions: Tax Efficiency and Risk Mitigation

Sophisticated investors recognize that maximizing wealth accumulation involves not only generating competitive returns but also optimizing the tax treatment of those returns and strategically managing portfolio risk.

Maximizing Self-Storage Tax Advantages

Self-storage offers several powerful mechanisms to enhance after-tax returns, a core component of “long-term real estate investing”:

1. Depreciation: As with all commercial properties, self-storage facilities are subject to depreciation, allowing investors to deduct the property’s cost gradually over 39 years.³² This non-cash expense reduces taxable income annually.
2. Cost Segregation and Bonus Depreciation: This is a crucial strategy for maximizing early-year tax benefits and capital velocity. An engineering-based Cost Segregation study identifies and reclassifies shorter-lived components of the facility (such as site improvements, specialized electrical systems, and security components) from the 39-year category into accelerated 5-, 7-, or 15-year depreciation schedules.³³

• This acceleration can shift 20% to 40% of the cost basis into shorter categories, resulting in substantial early-year deductions.³³ For instance, a quality study can generate $100,000 to $400,000 in federal tax benefits for every $1 million spent.³³
• Furthermore, Bonus Depreciation allows for the immediate (100%) expensing of these reclassified components, significantly boosting ROI and freeing up capital that would otherwise be owed in taxes, enabling immediate reinvestment.¹⁷

3. 1031 Exchange: Utilizing a 1031 Exchange allows investors to defer capital gains taxes on the sale of a property, provided the proceeds are reinvested into a like-kind replacement property, such as a self-storage facility.³² This tax deferral mechanism is essential for compounding wealth over multiple real estate cycles, allowing investors to trade into higher-value assets without premature tax liability.²²

The combined effect of cost segregation/bonus depreciation and the tax-free cash-out refinance mechanism (detailed in Section IV) maximizes capital velocity. Depreciation shields operational cash flow, while refinancing unlocks tax-free capital against appreciated value, making more funds available for immediate redeployment.

Portfolio Diversification and Liquidity Profile

Self-storage offers a distinct advantage in portfolio diversification due to its low correlation with traditional real estate markets.⁵ By adding a self-storage component, investors can safeguard against market volatility, as the sector’s performance often acts as a hedge when residential, office, or retail markets experience downturns.⁵ This characteristic makes self-storage an effective risk-mitigation tool and a resilient component of a diversified portfolio.³

While self-storage provides stability, investors must be aware of the inherent illiquidity associated with direct asset ownership or private syndication offerings. Unlike publicly traded REITs, private self-storage investments are generally illiquid, lacking a secondary market.³⁵ Liquidity is realized through planned capital events, such as asset disposition or refinancing.²⁰

The decline in overall transaction volume, down 57% year-over-year in the first half of 2023, demonstrates that exit timing is sensitive to capital market conditions, particularly the cost of debt.¹⁴ Investors should rely on the foundational operational strength of the asset and the sponsor’s financial stability to ensure successful exit potential, even amidst challenging debt markets.

---

Future Outlook: Industry Forecasts and Investment Trends (2024–2028)

The forecast for the self-storage sector indicates a market that is stabilizing after a post-pandemic surge, moving toward long-term constraints that favor existing asset owners.

Market Growth and Development Trends

The global self-storage market is projected to experience strong expansion, growing from an estimated $60.41 billion in 2024 to $107.36 billion by 2034.³⁶ This represents a projected CAGR of 5.92% from 2025 to 2034.³⁶ North America continues to lead the global market, accounting for 48% of the market share in 2024.³⁶

The short-term market challenge is the absorption of supply delivered during the high-growth phase of 2021 and 2022, when year-over-year deliveries jumped to approximately 3.5%.⁸ This elevated supply contributed to the softening of average asking rents and occupancy levels observed in 2024.⁸

Supply Pipeline Moderation and Scarcity Premium

The most critical factor supporting “long-term real estate investing” in this sector is the rapid and severe constriction of the new supply pipeline. Developers are pulling back significantly due to elevated construction costs, increased interest rates, and a lack of construction debt liquidity.⁸

Key pipeline indicators include:

• Construction Starts: Declined by 20% in 2024 compared to the previous year.⁷
• Under-Construction Pipeline: Shrank by 6.7% year-over-year.⁷
• Prospective Pipeline: Contracted by 25.3% year-over-year, signaling declining developer interest in launching new projects.⁷

Looking ahead, supply growth is projected to decelerate sharply, moderating to 2.0% of total inventory by 2027 and dropping further to 1.5% by 2029.⁷ This deep constraint on future competition is a powerful long-term catalyst for rent growth and property valuation for existing facilities. Furthermore, the time required for projects to navigate the planning phase has increased dramatically, averaging 583 days (19.4 months) in Q4 2024 before breaking ground.⁷ This extensive lag ensures that even if capital market conditions improve, new competitive supply will be significantly delayed, securing the near-term and mid-term profitability of assets acquired and stabilized today.

Investor Sentiment and Valuation Outlook

Investor sentiment in the sector remains generally positive, expecting a period of stability following the recent volatility. An investor survey conducted in Q2 2025 indicated that 56% of self-storage experts expect little to no change in capitalization rates over the following 12 months.¹³

While the market shows signs of stabilization, primary concerns influencing valuations and investor decisions are the slowing housing market (noted by 39% of respondents) and persistent interest rate uncertainty (35% of respondents).¹³ Despite these concerns, the sector’s fundamental stability and the projected slowdown in supply position self-storage favorably for investors seeking consistent cash flow and long-term capital appreciation over the 2024–2028 horizon.

---

Efficiency and Portfolio Synergy

Current market normalization, marked by stabilizing Cap Rates around 5.8% and a rapidly contracting supply pipeline, presents a high-yield entry point for well-capitalized investors. The projected slowdown in new supply growth to 1.5% of inventory by 2029 solidifies the long-term scarcity premium for existing assets. Furthermore, the robust tax advantages, particularly cost segregation and bonus depreciation, allow investors to maximize capital velocity, driving aggressive compounding of wealth. For the financially literate investor focused on risk-adjusted, long-term returns, self-storage offers a resilient, high-efficiency, and tax-advantaged path to sustained capital growth.

Key Takeaways

Mechanism	How It Builds Wealth	Investor Benefit
Cash Flow	Rent income exceeds lean operating costs	Generates consistent quarterly distributions
Equity Growth	NOI improvements drive higher asset valuations	Creates leverageable appreciation over time
Refinancing	Extract equity without selling the property	Enables portfolio expansion and liquidity
Tax Efficiency	Depreciation and deferral opportunities	Improves after-tax returns
Long-Term Holding	Compounding from multiple income streams	Maximizes cumulative ROI

Looking Ahead: Building Wealth with Discipline

The numbers confirm what seasoned investors already know, self-storage remains one of the most reliable, data-driven paths to long-term wealth creation in real estate.

Through stable cash flow, measurable equity growth, and strategic refinancing, disciplined operators like Dahn Corporation have demonstrated how a portfolio built on patient investment can outperform market cycles and generate lasting value.If you’d like to explore how self-storage could complement your real estate portfolio, reach out with a question today and our team can discuss current opportunities.

---

Works cited

1. The Stability and Comfort of Investing in Self-Storage Facilities, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.storagepointcapital.com/post/the-stability-and-comfort-of-investing-in-self-storage-facilities
2. The 6 Ds Of Self Storage Demand: The West Takes The Lead – StorageCafe, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.storagecafe.com/blog/the-6-ds-of-self-storage-where-demand-is-strongest-across-the-us/
3. Self-Storage as a Recession-Proof Investment – A-LERT BUILDING SYSTEMS, accessed October 20, 2025, https://alertbuildingsystems.com/self-storage-as-a-recession-proof-investment/
4. Spring 2025 Self-Storage Market Update – Storable, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.storable.com/resources/spring-2025-self-storage-market-update/
5. Diversifying Your Real Estate Portfolio with Self-Storage Investments, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.storagepointcapital.com/post/diversifying-your-real-estate-portfolio-with-self-storage-investments
6. How Is Real Estate Affecting the Self Storage Industry?, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.safkeep.com/blog/how-is-real-estate-affecting-the-self-storage-industry/
7. Self-Storage Outlook: Supply Growth Moderates Amid Rising Costs – CRE Daily, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.credaily.com/briefs/self-storage-outlook-supply-growth-moderates-amid-rising-costs/
8. Self Storage Market Trends & Investor Survey, accessed October 20, 2025, https://melestoragegroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Self-Storage-Market-Trends-Investor-Survey-H1-2024.pdf
9. Monthly Property Index Values & Returns – Nareit, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.reit.com/data-research/reit-indexes/monthly-property-index-values-returns
10. NCREIF Data, Index and Products Guide, accessed October 20, 2025, https://ncreif.org/__static/494f1e600333bddebfbf93e847412f47/NCREIF-Data-and-Products-Guide-2025.pdf
11. Self-Storage REITs: Strengthening Fundamentals and Solid Performance | Nareit, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.reit.com/news/articles/self-storage-reits-strengthening-fundamentals-and-solid-performance
12. Self Storage Market Trends Show Signs Of Stabilization In 2025 – CRE Daily, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.credaily.com/briefs/self-storage-market-trends-show-signs-of-stabilization-in-2025/
13. U.S. Self Storage: Market Trends & Sector Outlook – Cushman & Wakefield, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.cushmanwakefield.com/en/united-states/insights/us-self-storage-market-trends-and-sector-outlook
14. MARKET TRENDS & SECTOR OUTLOOK U.S. SELF STORAGE, accessed October 20, 2025, https://melestoragegroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/CWSSAG_Self-Storage-Performance-Quarterly-Overview-2023-H1_WEB.pdf
15. 2024 Self-Storage US Real Estate Market Value – Tract IQ, accessed October 20, 2025, https://tractiq.com/2024-self-storage-us-real-estate-market-value/
16. The PROS & CONS Of Self-Storage Investing By Kris Bennett – Next Level Income, accessed October 20, 2025, https://nextlevelincome.com/the-pros-cons-of-self-storage-investing-by-kris-bennett/
17. How To Invest in Self Storage via a Syndication + 7 Benefits To Know – RealWealth, accessed October 20, 2025, https://realwealth.com/learn/how-to-invest-in-self-storage-syndication/
18. What is a self-storage cap rate target? – Reliant Real Estate Management, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.reliant-mgmt.com/self-storage/self-storage-cap-rate-target
19. 2025 Leasing Season Recap and Takeaways – Storable, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.storable.com/resources/2025-leasing-season-recap-and-takeaways/
20. Investing in Self Storage: Complete Beginners Guide 2025 – Storeganise, accessed October 20, 2025, https://storeganise.com/blog/how-to-invest-in-self-storage
21. Proven Ways to Increase Revenue in Your Self Storage Business – Unit Trac, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.unittrac.com/blog/increase-self-storage-business-revenue
22. 1031 Exchanges and Self-Storage Facilities: Investing in a Booming Industry, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.1031specialists.com/blog-posts/1031-exchanges-and-self-storage-facilities-investing-in-a-booming-industry
23. Self-Storage Refinance: Your 2025 Guide – Commercial Real Estate Loans, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.commercialrealestate.loans/blog/self-storage-refinance-guide/
24. Self Storage Proforma Template – PropertyMetrics, accessed October 20, 2025, https://propertymetrics.com/self-storage-proforma-template/
25. Self Storage – Developer Financial Projection Template – ProjectionHub, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.projectionhub.com/financial-projection-template/self-storage-developer
26. What Self-Starters Should Know About Self-Storage Investment | LoopNet.com, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.loopnet.com/cre-explained/investing/what-self-starters-should-know-about-self-storage-investment/
27. Self Storage Case Study: 311% Returns? – Self Storage Income, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.selfstorageincome.com/blog/self-storage-case-study-311-returns
28. Prime Group to Receive $505M Refi for Self Storage Portfolio – Multi-Housing News, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.multihousingnews.com/prime-group-to-receive-505m-refi-for-self-storage-portfolio/
29. Unlocking Potential in Self-Storage Real Estate Investment, accessed October 20, 2025, https://perchwealth.com/investing-self-storage-real-estate-opportunity/
30. 9 Ways to Add Value to Your Self-Storage Facility – Janus International, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.janusintl.com/news-media/blog/adding-value-to-self-storage
31. European Self Storage Industry Report 2025 – CBRE, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.cbre.com/insights/reports/european-self-storage-industry-report-2025
32. Unlock Tax Advantages with Self-Storage Investments: Maximize Returns Through Depreciation and Deductions, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.storagepointcapital.com/post/unlock-tax-advantages-with-self-storage-investments-maximize-returns-through-depreciation-and-deductions
33. Cost Segregation Studies for Self-Storage Facilities – Capstan Tax Strategies, accessed October 20, 2025, https://capstantax.com/cost-segregation-studies-for-self-storage-facilities/
34. Self Storage Facility Cost Segregation Case Study | KBKG, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.kbkg.com/costsegregation/self-storage-facility-cost-segregation-case-study
35. Self Storage 1031 Investments: Maximizing Returns Through Strategic Exchanges, accessed October 20, 2025, https://perchwealth.com/self-storage-1031-investments/
36. Self-Storage Market Size to Hit USD 107.36 Billion by 2034 – Precedence Research, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.precedenceresearch.com/self-storage-market
37. Discover Self-storage REITs | Investing Tips, Data and More REITs – Nareit, accessed October 20, 2025, https://www.reit.com/what-reit/reit-sectors/self-storage
38. NCREIF Data, accessed October 20, 2025, http://ncreif.org/data/
39. NCREIF Query Tool, accessed October 20, 2025, https://user.ncreif.org/data-products/ncreif-query-tool/